Oops, you're using an old version of your browser so some of the features on this page may not be displaying properly.

MINIMAL Requirements: Google Chrome 24+Mozilla Firefox 20+Internet Explorer 11Opera 15–18Apple Safari 7SeaMonkey 2.15-2.23

About the ESMO-MCBS

In 2015 ESMO launched the ESMO-Magnitude of Clinical Benefit Scale (ESMO-MCBS) to facilitate improved decision-making regarding the value of anti-cancer therapies, promote the accessibility and reduce iniquity of access to high value cancer treatments.

The ESMO-MCBS was developed to promote the scientific integrity of ESMO and of oncologists and in particular to:

  • Reduce bias in data interpretation and analysis
  • Reduce hype
  • Robust validation with strict adherence to standards for “accountability for reasonableness”
  • Provide reliable and fair evaluation of benefit to assist in resource allocation decisions

Since value is based on considerations of the magnitude of clinical benefit as well as cost, and given the challenges to understanding the actual magnitude of the clinical benefit, the ESMO-MCBS was developed as a validated and reproducible scale that is applicable across the full range of solid tumours and soon in hematological malignancies.

It incorporates a structured, rational and valid approach to data interpretation and analysis that reduces the tendency to have judgements affected by bias or uninformed and/or idiosyncratic data interpretation that has been developed in accordance with the public policy standard of “accountability for reasonableness”.

It is a dynamic tool and its criteria are revised on a regular basis. The  ESMO- MCBS  was  revised in  2017 (version  1.1), based  on  feedback  and  queries  from  clinicians,  patients,  researchers  and  representatives  of  the  pharmaceutical  industry,  and  a  dynamic  process  of  internal  peer  review.

The ESMO-MCBS is intended to both assist oncologists in explaining the likely benefits of a particular treatment to their patient as well as to aid public health decision makers’ prioritise therapies for reimbursement. It  is  currently  incorporated in the ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines and is being used as part of Health Technology Assessment (HTA) processes.

ESMO-MCBS Scoring

The  ESMO-  MCBS  grading  highlights  those  treatments  which  substantially  improve  the  duration  of  survival  and/or  the  quality  of  life  (QoL)  of  patients  with  cancer  and  aims  to  distinguish  them  from  trials  demonstrating  more  limited  and  sometimes  even  marginal  benefits. The  ESMO-MCBS  assigns categorical benefit scores to European Medicines Agency  (EMA) and US Food and Drugs Administration (since January 2020) approved cancer medicines,  based  on  results  from  ‘positive’ randomised clinical trials:

  1. superiority trials that  have  demonstrated  a  statistically  significant  result  for  the  primary  endpoint  of  the  study,  or  secondary  in  case  of  overall  survival  and 
  2. non-inferiority  trials,  reaching  a  conclusion  of  non-inferiority. 

The scale considers overall survival, progression-free survival, disease free survival, hazard ratio, response rate, quality of life, prognosis of the condition and toxicity. There are 5 evaluation forms depending on the primary endpoint. More information on the evaluation forms can be found here.

Grading derived from the ESMO-MCBS provides a backbone for value evaluations for cancer medicines. Medicines and therapies that fall into the ESMO-MCBS A and B for curative therapies and 4 and 5 for non-curative therapies should be highlighted for accelerated assessment of value and cost-effectiveness. While a high ESMO-MCBS score does not automatically imply high value (that depends on the price), the scale can be used to frame such considerations and can help public policymakers advance ‘accountability for reasonableness’ in resource allocation deliberations.

The scoring process is reported below:

ESMO-MCBS-Scoring-Process

Read the pivotal articles of the ESMO-MCBS:

This site uses cookies. Some of these cookies are essential, while others help us improve your experience by providing insights into how the site is being used.

For more detailed information on the cookies we use, please check our Privacy Policy.

Customise settings
  • Necessary cookies enable core functionality. The website cannot function properly without these cookies, and you can only disable them by changing your browser preferences.